Nope, that didn't do it. My limits on the meta tags were going to be 200 for the description and 650 characters for keywords. That should have been perfect.

With 10000 limits, the same thing happens... I add the first meta description and it takes it. I add another one and I get the error. And for another little twist, I added a meta description to my first category and it worked. I then deleted the meta description from the first category and added the same description to the second category and I got the error. Then I shortened that description and tried it in the second category again, and it worked. Very strange.