Mailing List Archive: Linux-HA: Users

Shutdown node ---> Voting and never going down....

Index | Next | Previous | View Threaded

cyruspy at gmail

Nov 11, 2009, 12:24 PM

Post #1 of 5 (976 views)
Permalink

Shutdown node ---> Voting and never going down....

Hi, I just made some network configuration changes in a 2 node
cluster, now we are using bonding. On the first reboot of one of the
nodes I see some kind of election on the logs and the node never goes
down...

Any ideas?

-------
============
Last updated: Wed Nov 11 17:24:06 2009
Current DC: asusis-xen2 (e02dd28f-56e7-4138-bb64-2dcd6e20d6fc)
2 Nodes configured.
2 Resources configured.
============

Node: asusis-xen1 (553269a3-750a-4ebd-afd5-f467ced146af): standby
Node: asusis-xen2 (e02dd28f-56e7-4138-bb64-2dcd6e20d6fc): standby
-------

-----------
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info:
do_election_count_vote: Election won over asusis-xen2
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info:
do_election_count_vote: Election check: vote from asusis-xen2
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info:
do_election_count_vote: Election won over asusis-xen2
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info:
do_election_count_vote: Election check: vote from asusis-xen2
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info:
do_election_count_vote: Election won over asusis-xen2
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: WARN: do_log: [[FSA]] Input
I_JOIN_OFFER from route_message() received in state (S_ELECTION)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info:
do_election_count_vote: Updated voted hash for asusis-xen1 to vote
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info:
do_election_count_vote: Election ignore: our vote (asusis-xen1)
Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
Still waiting on 1 non-votes (2 total)
-----------

Regards,

--
Ciro Iriarte
http://cyruspy.wordpress.com
--
_______________________________________________
Linux-HA mailing list
Linux-HA [at] lists
http://lists.linux-ha.org/mailman/listinfo/linux-ha
See also: http://linux-ha.org/ReportingProblems

cyruspy at gmail

Nov 11, 2009, 12:26 PM

Post #2 of 5 (888 views)
Permalink

Re: Shutdown node ---> Voting and never going down.... [In reply to]

2009/11/11 Ciro Iriarte <cyruspy [at] gmail>:
> Hi, I just made some network configuration changes in a 2 node
> cluster, now we are using bonding. On the first reboot of one of the
> nodes I see some kind of election on the logs and the node never goes
> down...
>
> Any ideas?
>
> -------
> ============
> Last updated: Wed Nov 11 17:24:06 2009
> Current DC: asusis-xen2 (e02dd28f-56e7-4138-bb64-2dcd6e20d6fc)
> 2 Nodes configured.
> 2 Resources configured.
> ============
>
> Node: asusis-xen1 (553269a3-750a-4ebd-afd5-f467ced146af): standby
> Node: asusis-xen2 (e02dd28f-56e7-4138-bb64-2dcd6e20d6fc): standby
> -------
>
> -----------
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info:
> do_election_count_vote: Election won over asusis-xen2
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info:
> do_election_count_vote: Election check: vote from asusis-xen2
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info:
> do_election_count_vote: Election won over asusis-xen2
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info:
> do_election_count_vote: Election check: vote from asusis-xen2
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info:
> do_election_count_vote: Election won over asusis-xen2
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: WARN: do_log: [[FSA]] Input
> I_JOIN_OFFER from route_message() received in state (S_ELECTION)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 2 non-votes (2 total)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info:
> do_election_count_vote: Updated voted hash for asusis-xen1 to vote
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info:
> do_election_count_vote: Election ignore: our vote (asusis-xen1)
> Nov 11 17:23:35 asusis-xen1 crmd: [29463]: info: do_election_check:
> Still waiting on 1 non-votes (2 total)
> -----------
>
> Regards,
>

Forgot to mention:

Package from OBS: heartbeat-2.99.0-2.1
OS: SLES10SP2

Regards,

--
Ciro Iriarte
http://cyruspy.wordpress.com
--
_______________________________________________
Linux-HA mailing list
Linux-HA [at] lists
http://lists.linux-ha.org/mailman/listinfo/linux-ha
See also: http://linux-ha.org/ReportingProblems

lmb at suse

Nov 13, 2009, 5:43 AM

Post #3 of 5 (869 views)
Permalink

Re: Shutdown node ---> Voting and never going down.... [In reply to]

On 2009-11-11T17:26:05, Ciro Iriarte <cyruspy [at] gmail> wrote:

> Package from OBS: heartbeat-2.99.0-2.1
> OS: SLES10SP2

How about upgrading to the maintenance packages, instead of running the
OBS code? Then Novell support will be glad to help ;-)

If you need the non-product code for some reason, I'd suggest running at
least the latest pacemaker+hb packages, if you're not yet willing to
upgrade to corosync/openais. The community tends to prefer the latest
code version in support questions.

Regards,
Lars

--
Architect Storage/HA, OPS Engineering, Novell, Inc.
SUSE LINUX Products GmbH, GF: Markus Rex, HRB 16746 (AG N�rnberg)
"Experience is the name everyone gives to their mistakes." -- Oscar Wilde

_______________________________________________
Linux-HA mailing list
Linux-HA [at] lists
http://lists.linux-ha.org/mailman/listinfo/linux-ha
See also: http://linux-ha.org/ReportingProblems

cyruspy at gmail

Nov 13, 2009, 6:07 AM

Post #4 of 5 (857 views)
Permalink

Re: Shutdown node ---> Voting and never going down.... [In reply to]

2009/11/13 Lars Marowsky-Bree <lmb [at] suse>:
> On 2009-11-11T17:26:05, Ciro Iriarte <cyruspy [at] gmail> wrote:
>
>> Package from OBS: heartbeat-2.99.0-2.1
>> OS: SLES10SP2
>
> How about upgrading to the maintenance packages, instead of running the
> OBS code? Then Novell support will be glad to help ;-)
>
> If you need the non-product code for some reason, I'd suggest running at
> least the latest pacemaker+hb packages, if you're not yet willing to
> upgrade to corosync/openais. The community tends to prefer the latest
> code version in support questions.
>
>
> Regards,
> Lars
>

We do have support, but the provided packages are really old.... It
has been working fine, it exploded after the changes... I'll schedule
an upgrade to the latest packages from OBS. I'm using OCFS2+heartbeat,
so I'm not sure if the upgrade to openais would be easy...

Regards,

--
Ciro Iriarte
http://cyruspy.wordpress.com
--
_______________________________________________
Linux-HA mailing list
Linux-HA [at] lists
http://lists.linux-ha.org/mailman/listinfo/linux-ha
See also: http://linux-ha.org/ReportingProblems

lmb at suse

Nov 13, 2009, 9:43 AM

Post #5 of 5 (856 views)
Permalink

Re: Shutdown node ---> Voting and never going down.... [In reply to]

On 2009-11-13T11:07:50, Ciro Iriarte <cyruspy [at] gmail> wrote:

> We do have support, but the provided packages are really old....

The 2.1.4 packages in the update channel actually contain serious fixes
and backports.

And no, you do not have support, at least no system support will help
you with. But I guess you are aware of that when you installed the
non-channel upgrades.

> It has been working fine, it exploded after the changes... I'll
> schedule an upgrade to the latest packages from OBS.

To be honest, I've been neglecting the OBS packages a bit recently.
(Because OBS has been facing some build-power challenges, and I've been
extremely busy with SLE HA 11.) I think Andrew is in the process of
producing newer packages of Pacemaker too though.

> I'm using OCFS2+heartbeat, so I'm not sure if the upgrade to openais
> would be easy...

Actually, the Filesystem RA would still switch to the compatibility mode
on SLES10, so that should work. But if you do have an active support
subscription, of course you have a free-of-charge path to upgrade to
SLES11/SLE HA 11, which includes a rather well-working
OpenAIS/Pacemaker/OCFS2 stack all ready to roll.

Regards,
Lars

--
Architect Storage/HA, OPS Engineering, Novell, Inc.
SUSE LINUX Products GmbH, GF: Markus Rex, HRB 16746 (AG N�rnberg)
"Experience is the name everyone gives to their mistakes." -- Oscar Wilde

_______________________________________________
Linux-HA mailing list
Linux-HA [at] lists
http://lists.linux-ha.org/mailman/listinfo/linux-ha
See also: http://linux-ha.org/ReportingProblems

Index | Next | Previous | View Threaded

Interested in having your list archived? Contact Gossamer Threads